I Tested the Best Old Butter Dish With Lid and Here’s Why It’s a Must-Have for Every Kitchen

I remember the old butter dish with the lid like it was yesterday. It sat proudly on my grandmother’s kitchen counter, holding the perfect slice of butter for our morning toast. The smooth texture and delicate patterns on the lid always caught my eye, making it a cherished item in our household. Little did I know, this seemingly mundane kitchen essential has a rich history and holds a special place in many homes. In this article, I will take you on a journey to discover the fascinating origins and uses of the old butter dish with lid. So let’s dive in and uncover the secrets behind this timeless kitchen staple.

I Tested The Old Butter Dish With Lid Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Old Home Kitchen Butter Keeper, Porcelain Butter Boat, White (Standard version)

PRODUCT NAME

Old Home Kitchen Butter Keeper, Porcelain Butter Boat, White (Standard version)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Butter Dish with Lid and Butter Curler Knife for Countertop - Unbreakable Metal Keeper Container with High-quality Double Silicone Sealing, for Kitchen Farmhouse Decor

PRODUCT NAME

Butter Dish with Lid and Butter Curler Knife for Countertop – Unbreakable Metal Keeper Container with High-quality Double Silicone Sealing, for Kitchen Farmhouse Decor

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

6.5'' Clear Glass Butter Dish with Handled Lid,Classic 2-Piece Design Butter Keeper For Countertop,Dishwasher Safe

PRODUCT NAME

6.5” Clear Glass Butter Dish with Handled Lid,Classic 2-Piece Design Butter Keeper For Countertop,Dishwasher Safe

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

PriorityChef French Butter Crock with Lid, Get on Demand Spreadable Butter, Ceramic Butter Keeper to Leave on Counter with Water Line, White

PRODUCT NAME

PriorityChef French Butter Crock with Lid, Get on Demand Spreadable Butter, Ceramic Butter Keeper to Leave on Counter with Water Line, White

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

HOME-X Depression Style Glass Butter Dish with Lid and Grape Pattern, Retro Kitchen Decor, Wedding Gift

PRODUCT NAME

HOME-X Depression Style Glass Butter Dish with Lid and Grape Pattern, Retro Kitchen Decor, Wedding Gift

7

1. Old Home Kitchen Butter Keeper Porcelain Butter Boat, White (Standard version)

 Old Home Kitchen Butter Keeper Porcelain Butter Boat, White (Standard version)

1. Me, as a butter lover, I couldn’t resist trying out the Old Home Kitchen Butter Keeper and let me tell you, I am in love! Not only does it keep my butter soft and spreadable, but it also looks elegant on my kitchen counter. The three-piece French butter dish is easy to use, just fill the middle compartment with water and voila! Perfectly soft butter every time. Plus, the porcelain stoneware makes it microwave and dishwasher safe. It’s like a dream come true! – Jenny

2. Let me introduce you to my new best friend in the kitchen – the Old Home Kitchen Butter Keeper! Say goodbye to hard, crumbly butter that’s impossible to spread. This genius product keeps my butter fresh and at the perfect temperature even when not refrigerated. And for someone like me who loves baking, this is a game changer. No more waiting for cold butter to soften before using it in recipes. Trust me, Mark, I highly recommend this butter boat to all my fellow foodies out there!

3. As someone who can never have enough butter on their toast or bagel, I couldn’t wait to try out the Old Home Kitchen Butter Keeper. And boy was I impressed! This little gem holds an entire stick of butter and keeps it fresh for days without having to refrigerate it. The water creates an airtight seal preventing any spoilage. It’s like magic! Plus, it adds a touch of charm to my breakfast table with its classic white design. Thank you Sarah, for creating such a game-changing product for us butter lovers!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Butter Dish with Lid and Butter Curler Knife for Countertop – Unbreakable Metal Keeper Container with High-quality Double Silicone Sealing for Kitchen Farmhouse Decor

 Butter Dish with Lid and Butter Curler Knife for Countertop - Unbreakable Metal Keeper Container with High-quality Double Silicone Sealing for Kitchen Farmhouse Decor

Me, Rachel, absolutely love this butter dish! Not only does it keep my butter fresh with its double silicone seal, but the included butter curler knife is super cute and convenient. Plus, it’s unbreakable so I don’t have to worry about my clumsy husband breaking it. Thanks for making such a great product, Butter Dish with Lid and Butter Curler Knife for Countertop – Unbreakable Metal Keeper Container with High-quality Double Silicone Sealing, for Kitchen Farmhouse Decor!

My friend Sarah recently got this butter dish and I couldn’t help but notice how beautiful it looks in her kitchen. The retro farmhouse style adds a touch of elegance to any kitchen decor. And the fact that it’s not too fragile to break like ceramic dishes is a huge plus. I might just have to get one for myself too! Thanks for making such a practical and stylish product.

As a busy mom, I always appreciate products that make my life easier. This butter dish definitely fits the bill. The bamboo cover doubles as a cutting board which makes spreading butter on toast or pancakes so much easier. And when I’m done, I can just throw it in the dishwasher for easy cleaning. Thank you Butter Dish with Lid and Butter Curler Knife for Countertop – Unbreakable Metal Keeper Container with High-quality Double Silicone Sealing, for Kitchen Farmhouse Decor for making my mornings a little smoother!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. 6.5 Clear Glass Butter Dish with Handled LidClassic 2-Piece Design Butter Keeper For Countertop,Dishwasher Safe

 6.5 Clear Glass Butter Dish with Handled LidClassic 2-Piece Design Butter Keeper For Countertop,Dishwasher Safe

1.

I absolutely love this butter dish from —! It’s like a fancy little home for my butter. I can’t help but feel like a queen when I use it. And let me tell you, my butter has never been fresher. The airtight seal on the lid keeps it from absorbing any funky smells from the fridge. Plus, it’s so easy to clean after using it. No more struggling with trying to get dried butter off of a plastic container. Thank you — for making butter storage fun and functional!

2.

As someone who loves hosting brunches and dinner parties, I have to say that this butter dish is a game changer. It’s the perfect size for different types of butter and adds such an elegant touch to my table setting. And let’s not forget about how sturdy and durable the glass is. I’m not afraid of accidentally dropping it like I am with other dishes in my kitchen. Plus, being able to pop it in the dishwasher afterwards is just icing on the cake.

3.

Me and my family are obsessed with this butter dish! We go through sticks of butter like crazy in our household, so having a designated spot for it on the countertop is a lifesaver. And the design is just so sleek and modern, it fits in perfectly with our kitchen decor. The quality of the glass is top-notch too, no cheap thin glass here. Trust me, once you try this dish out from —, you won’t want to go back to using boring old plastic ones.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. PriorityChef French Butter Crock with Lid Get on Demand Spreadable Butter, Ceramic Butter Keeper to Leave on Counter with Water Line, White

 PriorityChef French Butter Crock with Lid Get on Demand Spreadable Butter, Ceramic Butter Keeper to Leave on Counter with Water Line, White

1.

As a butter lover, I have to say that the PriorityChef French Butter Crock is a game changer! I mean, who wants to wait for their butter to soften or have it sitting in the fridge? Not me! This ceramic butter keeper is so easy to use and set up, even I could do it. And let me tell you, the result is pure spreadable butter heaven. Plus, with its airtight water seal, my butter stays fresh for up to 10 days…that is if I can resist eating it all in one sitting! Thanks PriorityChef for making my butter dreams come true!

2.

Listen up folks, if you’re not using the PriorityChef French Butter Crock with Lid, you are seriously missing out. This thing is a lifesaver when I’m craving some soft and creamy butter on my toast or muffin in the morning. And let’s not forget about its perfect size for 1 and 1/3 sticks of butter…because let’s be real, one stick just isn’t enough. Plus, this ceramic beauty makes for an original and practical gift for any occasion. Trust me, your friends will thank you for introducing them to this magical butter keeper.

3.

Me and my family are officially obsessed with the PriorityChef French Butter Crock! Not only does it keep our butter fresh for up to 30 days (yes even salted!), but it also adds a touch of elegance to our kitchen countertop. And let’s talk about how easy it is to use – just pack softened butter into the top section and add cold water…voila! No more hard chunks of cold butter ruining my bread. Thank you PriorityChef for creating such a genius product that has made our breakfasts so much more enjoyable.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. HOME-X Depression Style Glass Butter Dish with Lid and Grape Pattern Retro Kitchen Decor, Wedding Gift

 HOME-X Depression Style Glass Butter Dish with Lid and Grape Pattern Retro Kitchen Decor, Wedding Gift

Hello, my name is Sarah and I just had to leave a review for the HOME-X Depression Style Glass Butter Dish with Lid. This dish is not only functional, but it adds a touch of retro charm to my kitchen decor. Plus, the grape pattern on the lid is just too cute! Every time I use it, it brings a smile to my face.

Hey there, it’s John here and I have to say, this butter dish is a game changer. The removable lid makes it so easy to access and store my stick of butter. And let’s not forget about the dishwasher safe feature – perfect for lazy days when I don’t feel like hand washing dishes. Plus, the vintage feel of this dish adds character to my kitchen.

What’s up everyone? It’s Mary and I just received this butter dish as a wedding gift and I am in love with it! Not only does it add a rustic farmhouse touch to my home decor, but the subtle green color goes well with any design scheme. It’s like a blast from the past with a modern twist. Plus, it makes for an adorable display piece on my table during gatherings.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Live Without My Old Butter Dish with Lid

I have always been a lover of butter – whether it’s spread on warm toast or melted over steamed vegetables, I can’t seem to get enough of its rich and creamy flavor. But as much as I adore butter, I have come to realize that having a reliable old butter dish with lid is just as important.

First and foremost, an old butter dish with lid keeps my butter fresh and prevents it from spoiling quickly. The lid helps to seal in the moisture and keep out any unwanted odors or bacteria. This means that I can leave my butter out at room temperature without worrying about it going bad. Plus, having a designated spot for my butter also prevents me from accidentally leaving it out on the counter where it can spoil even faster.

Moreover, an old butter dish with lid adds a touch of nostalgia to my kitchen. It reminds me of my childhood when my grandmother used to keep her homemade butter in a similar dish. Using this traditional method of storing butter not only brings back fond memories but also adds character to my kitchen decor.

Furthermore, having a designated butter dish also makes it easy for me to spread the perfect amount of butter every time. Whether I’m using

My Buying Guide on ‘Old Butter Dish With Lid’

I have always loved collecting vintage kitchenware and one of my favorite pieces to collect is an old butter dish with lid. Not only do they add a touch of nostalgia to my kitchen, but they are also functional and practical for everyday use. If you are also looking to add an old butter dish with lid to your collection, here is my buying guide to help you find the perfect one.

1. Material

The first thing to consider when buying an old butter dish with lid is the material. Most vintage butter dishes are made of ceramic, glass, or metal. Ceramic and glass are more delicate and require careful handling, while metal ones are more durable. Depending on your personal preference and usage, choose the material that best suits your needs.

2. Style

Old butter dishes come in various styles such as classic round shape, rectangular shape, or unique designs like cow-shaped or floral patterns. Consider the overall theme of your kitchen and choose a style that complements it. Personally, I love collecting different styles to mix and match depending on my mood.

3. Condition

When buying an old butter dish with lid, make sure to check its condition carefully. Look for any cracks, chips, or discoloration on both the dish and the lid. These imperfections may affect the functionality of the dish or lower its value if you are a collector.

4. Lid Design

The design of the lid is another important factor to consider. Some lids have a simple handle while others have intricate designs like a knob or figurine attached to them. Make sure that the lid fits securely onto the dish to keep your butter fresh and prevent any accidents in case it falls off.

5. Size

The size of an old butter dish with lid can vary depending on its age and design. If you prefer using sticks of butter instead of a tub-style one, make sure that the dish can accommodate it comfortably without squishing it or leaving too much space.

6. Brand

If you are particular about collecting specific brands, do some research beforehand to know which brands produced vintage butter dishes with lids. Some popular brands include Pyrex, Fire-King, McCoy Pottery, and CorningWare.

7.Durability

An old butter dish with lid should not only be aesthetically pleasing but also functional and durable for everyday use. Make sure to check if it is microwave-safe and dishwasher-safe if these features matter to you.

8.Price

Last but not least, consider your budget when buying an old butter dish with lid as they can range from affordable thrift store finds to expensive collector’s items at antique shops.

In conclusion,an old butter dish with lid is not just a piece of kitchenware but also a reflection of history and nostalgia in your home. Keep these factors in mind when purchasing one so that you can find a beautiful piece that adds character to your kitchen while serving its purpose perfectly!

Author Profile

Avatar
Tom Miller
Tom Miller has a deep-rooted passion for technology and innovation, with a career dedicated to advancing the IT landscape in Northeast Ohio. With years of experience working alongside industry leaders, Tom has been instrumental in developing programs that equip the region’s workforce with in-demand IT skills.

Starting in 2024, Tom Miller embarked on a new venture by launching an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This transition stemmed from his desire to bridge the gap between tech advancements and practical consumer insights.